Monday, January 23, 2012

Teaching and Learning


Students with top teachers are less likely to become pregnant as teenagers, more likely to enroll in college, and more likely to earn more money as adults – NYTimes.com
These are some of the answers given when students were asked to write a response to the following question, Why do you want to be a teacher?
Let’s start with the confusing and disturbingly bad responses. Clearly, writing, nor mastery of English are strengths, as these are presented here just as they were presented to me. I mean, really people, these kids are going to become teachers and shape the future of Ghana. Sigh…..
“I want to be a teacher so as to impact knowledge acquired to the public for the continuation of education.”
“A teacher as expected of is supposed to learned and more equipped with knowledge and skills which he is to impact in learners.”
“I want to be a teacher because I have the ability to teach for other people to understand, and also react politely to other peoples actions.”
“Teaching is a kind of profession that makes one to life a simply and decent life. Jesus Christ start the teaching work by teaching the word of God. So firstly I want to be a teacher so as to live simply and desent life on this earth.”
Moving on to the powerful and meaningful responses. These lead me to believe that there is some hope here.
“I want to be a teacher so that I will help people solve their problems and also to free people from ignorance. To help young people develop their talent and transform them to become leaders who will rule the country with justice.”
“I would like to be a teacher because the developing nature of a country depends on education. In becoming a teacher I will help in the development of my country to make people get knowledge.”
“I want to be a teacher because I have the passion for the job. I want to be able to mold people to be responsible in the future.”
“To help develop my country by teaching others and to reduce the illiteracy rate.”
End of semester exams begin this week. Pressure and panic have engulfed the campus. Students take 9 exams this semester. Ridiculous. A friend of mine texted me last week saying that she gave her students every answer to the questions on her quiz, and they still cheated. The cheating is prompted by the panic that sets in at the moment when a student realizes they have not memorized every bit of knowledge “imparted” upon them. Herein lies the problem.
The emphasis at this teacher-training college is on memorization of content of every subject under the sun. It’s a rushed process with the teacher-training colleges trying to prepare students in two years. Two years where there are a lot of days off and a lot of late-starting classes, so ultimately, the number of minutes actually spent engaged in learning is relatively low for what is needed. In addition to the rush, it’s information overload! Sure, kids are going to school. Students are enrolled in these “colleges”, but the quality of the education is the problem here. Teaching shouldn’t just be about “imparting knowledge”, which is a phrase I have heard over and over and over again here. Teaching should be about developing understanding, encouraging thinking, and facilitating learning. Imparting knowledge is just a small piece of the puzzle, in my opinion.
While here, I am taking a few online classes with DePaul to finish my special education endorsement. Since the reading specialist program at DePaul, I have become highly interested in students with special needs. Special education is a fascinating field and there is so much to learn! Yes, I am nerd to the max. I am loving this class and the continued acquisition of knowledge in my life. So what if I’m in debt for the rest of my life? I might just keep going to college and wracking up these degrees and endorsements. Ultimately, I hope to some day really have a say-so in a school whether that be through a leadership role or as a founding member of a new school. Big dreams.....can't help myself :)

Unfortunately, this class and my observations are teaching me that special education in Ghana is a sad state of affairs. Instruction about special education at the college level is minimal and is covered in this one teeny tiny "textbook" you see here. Clearly not much attention is given to the field. There are schools for blind and deaf children, but if you have a learning disability, there really isn’t anything for you. If a student with a learning disability is lucky enough to get a good teacher who cares, then he/she might thrive, but generally speaking, what I’m hearing about the system is very disheartening.
Ghana is really fueling my passion for education. A few years out of the classroom has me really pumped up again about teaching, specifically struggling learners. My experiences with education here are teaching me so much about what kind of teacher I want to be and what qualities I believe an effective school must possess. Can't wait to get back to the U.S. education system!

23 comments:

  1. I agree with the New York Times quote because if students have teachers in their lives that are influential, they may want to succeed and make positive decisions.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I disagree with the New York Times quote. I think that most of the things listed, like getting pregnant as a teenager has nothing to do with a teacher.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think that there were good and bad student responses.

    ReplyDelete
  4. What are the students like in Ghana?

    ReplyDelete
  5. 1. my thoughts on the NY quote was that i agree with the quote because, when you have teachers that care about your future and that are on you so you can succeed shows that they care where you end up in the long run. as to where if you had a teacher that really never cared what you did in class shows people that it doesn't matter where you end up in the long run.



    2.with the students response it seems like they must care about having a good quality teacher to help the succeed and get through tough situations.



    3.he response shows that she isn't there to get props she is there because she actually cares about how they feel and like where they would want to go in the future instead of letting the talent go to waste.




    4.my question is: like is the experience of being there stressful at some points?
    another question is do you think most of your students will succeed?


    T.G!

    ReplyDelete
  6. 1. When taking what was said in the NYT's quote into consideration I don't think that top teachers have a huge effect on teens becoming pregnant. There are many teachers here at our school who may be considered top teachers but students still become pregnant although I can agree that maybe teachers are an influence on teens on how to have respect for themselves and can help them stay focused on their future. As far as the rest of the quote goes i agree completely with it.

    2. I think that most of the students post are great responses to why they want to be a teacher. Some of their answers are one sentence response and you would think that if someone wanted to be a teacher they'd want their students to answer with more then one short sentence.

    3. I agree completely when you say that teaching is more then about imparting knowledge and most people did say that.

    4. With the NYT's quote, How do you feel about the impact teachers have on teenage pregnancy and do you think being a "top teacher" can make a difference on students actions that would lead them to teenage pregnancy?

    ReplyDelete
  7. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I agree with your response to the students responses.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I think the worst response was: “Teaching is a kind of profession that makes one to life a simply and decent life. Jesus Christ start the teaching work by teaching the word of God. So firstly I want to be a teacher so as to live simply and desent life on this earth.”

    Because you dont have to be a teacher to live a descent life, and im sure all teachers dont have a simple life.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Do you like Africa?

    ReplyDelete
  11. 1. My opinion on the NY Times quote is that it is true that if students have a caring teacher they feel like someone actually cares about them because not everyone comes from a family that is caring and loving so having a teacher like that can benefit the students in the future.
    2. Some of the responses were really good and they seemed like they really wanted to become teachers because they wanted to help to further education.
    3. I like the way you responded to how the students answer your question some of them seem like they really don't need to become teachers.
    4. I would like to know why you chose to go to Ghana?

    ReplyDelete
  12. I agree with your responses

    ReplyDelete
  13. That is true because you are less likely to become pregnant because when they have the top teacher they focus more on there studies and more likely to finish school and not worry about having kids.

    ReplyDelete
  14. 1. My response to NYT's quote is that although teachers play a big role in a students life they are not the only role. I think their statistics may be a little over generalized. Much more comes into play in a child's life such as their family, their friends, their environment, etc. No matter how good of a teacher they may have it takes a really personal relationship with a student to make large enough of an impact to influence that child to have safe sex, go to college and get a good job. In just one school year it is nearly impossible for even the greatest of teachers to make that large of an impact in all of their students life's. Although making the impact in just one student's life is a success.

    2. I think most of the students had good responses as to why they want to become a teacher. Although some could definitely use help with their grammar skills.

    3. Amy, I think you are definitely right when it comes to the quality of education. It shouldn't be so much about cramming all the information into their heads in the shortest amount of time but rather providing them with a quality education where they may actually learn and take things in so that they too can provide that quality education to the country of Ghana.

    4. Amy, what inspired you to go all the way to Ghana to teach?

    ReplyDelete
  15. i think that some of the teachers had good reasons of why they wanted to be a teacher. But the sad part was when kids with disability they couldn't help. I think her comment back was honest. And it was her opinion.
    4. My question is why did you decide to go to africa.

    ReplyDelete
  16. that's true because most women become pregnant when they have the top teacher to help them cdy

    ReplyDelete
  17. 1. my opinion about they NewYork times, i agree with this blog because it is right, you got to have the right teacher that cares for you because not everybody has someone that cares for them. some children gets taking out their homes because they feel like there parents don't care for them, and if its not for that teacher to care for them, then they going to be hurt and shut down.
    2. your students have some great responses on why they want to be a teacher, they give you really good answer on why they want to and stuff that they can help kids do if they become a teacher. i really like the one that the student said that jesus christ made the teaching work by teaching the word of god and that is totally true.
    3. she had a really good opinion about the schooling up there, yes it is truly sad that they can't help out people with learning disability. the kids with learning disability wants to learn like everybody else, they are all the same as everybody else. when i read that part i had tears coming to my eyes because that was so sad.
    4. so what made you go Ghana?
    do you love it there?
    <3 always, an high school student: Tyesha Majors

    ReplyDelete
  18. Nadija--I agree with you completely! Think about the amount of time in your life that you spend with teachers. Teachers are inevitably going to influence you in some way. And I believe that many teachers are trying to be positive influences and lead students towards the right path.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Lindsey -- I agree with you to an extent. Everyone makes their own personal decisions and are ultimately responsible for their own choices. But I think the encouragement of a teacher can be helpful. Teachers can expose students to options and get them thinking about all of the possibilities there are in life, besides pregnancy. College, traveling, trade school, starting your own business.

    In response to, "what are the students like in Ghana?" - The college students I am teaching are very kind and helpful. However, only a small percentage of them are very serious about their studies. Most of the students are only worried about doing well on their exams, rather than working on becoming excellent teachers. Teacher quality is a big problem in Ghana, so it is unfortunate that students don't work harder in college. My only experience is at this college though, so I cannot say how students are at other schools. I have worked a little bit with a local primary school, and the students there are very enthusiastic and always happy.

    Yes, this experience has been stressful at times. The first two months that I was here were very very difficult. I felt lonely and confused and I missed the comforts of home. However, with time, I have become more at ease here and happy. I thought about quitting and going home when I was feeling my worst, but I am so glad that I stuck it out. Now I have reached the point of being very appreciative for this opportunity. I am learning so much about Ghana and myself. Ultimately, I think this experience is making me a better person and a better teacher.

    I believe some of the students will succeed. Like I mentioned above though, unfortunately some of them do not take their classes very seriously. I fear that many of the students here do not feel very passionately about being a teacher. But, I know the ones that really care will be great teachers because they work hard and ask a lot of questions.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Caley -- I think being a "top" teacher can be a very powerful role. As I mentioned to Nadija above, young people spend a large portion of their life with teachers. We are all influenced somewhat by the people in our lives. A teacher has the potential to really influence a young person's decisions by informing them about the world and all of the possibilities out there. Being educated opens your mind to new ways of life and new ways of thinking. A great teacher will inspire students to read books, go to college, and travel. And that same great teacher will be honest with students about how having a baby as a teenager will drastically impact the rest of their life. WIth a truly exceptional teacher, I think students can make more informed decisions about their own lives because that teacher has worked really hard to educate and inform and inspire.

    Lindsey - I do like Africa. It is very very different though, which has been challenging at times. I am enjoying the warmth. It is sunny and warm every day! The people here in Ghana are exceptionally kind and helpful. Much more so than the people in Chicago. I feel appreciated and welcome here. It is nice.

    DMN - I came to Ghana three years ago for one month over a summer. When I applied to this program for teaching, I did not choose Ghana. Instead, I was assigned to Ghana, and I was very grateful to get to come back to a place I had previously been. I chose to teach here because I wanted to share my knowledge. The quality of education in Ghana is not very good, and I knew that I would be able to make a positive impact on the education system with my years of teaching experience and educational background.

    Summer - In addition to what I just wrote to DMN, I wanted to teach in Africa because I feel very strongly about the power of education, specifically literacy. Being a good reader can help you to make more informed decisions and can also help you to make a change in the world around you. Much of Africa is living in deep poverty, and the only way to change that is with education. I wanted to help improve the education system here by helping teachers get better at their jobs. Better teachers will better help young people. In time, those young people will eventually make business and development decisions for this country. The more educated they are, the smarter their decisions will be.

    zztop & tyesha - Please read my previous responses here about why I chose to come to Africa. I do enjoy Ghana, but at the same time, I miss the U.S. I am glad that I am here and am truly enjoying the experience. I am meeting very interesting people and I am getting to see some beautiful places. In addition, I am helping improve a nation's education system. To me, that is very powerful.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. well i am glad that you had the heart to go africa, most people they won't do that because they don't have the heart to, but i am glad you helping to improve a nations education system in africa.
      thanks for replying back to my comment that means a lot to me.
      so is there anything up there that you dislike, that you wish that can change?

      Delete
    2. well i am glad that you are having an excellent time, and i am glad you went there to help improve a nations education system.
      i am glad you responded back to me, that means a lot to me
      are there anything in africa that you dislike, like in there teaching area???

      Delete
  21. Reed - I like how you simply summarized the message of the NYTimes quote. Good teachers can be very powerful influences, because they are informing teenagers about the other options in life besides getting pregnant at such a young age. However, I also agree with what Summer wrote. Teachers are not the only influences in a young person's life. Teenagers are also very strongly influenced by their peers. In my opinion though, a person is ultimately responsible for his/her own decisions. Teachers, parents, and friends are simply guide-posts along the way.

    ReplyDelete